Find What You’ve Been Searching for at America’s Antique Mall in Indiana

Why would you go antique shopping the old-fashioned way, driving all over Indiana to hit up antique shop after antique shop, when you can find hundreds of stores under one roof? With each visit to your Indiana antique mall, you’ll find fresh items to explore, so the treasure hunt never gets old.

You Can Find the Pieces that Tell Your Story in an Indiana Antique Mall

With more than 350 booths and 350+ glass showcases of antique, vintage, upcycled, and artisan items to explore, there’s bound to be something for everyone at our Indiana antique mall. Whether you’re searching for an ultra-rare Star Wars trading card or a vintage Cubs hat, one thing is certain: your odds of finding it among our large inventory are significantly higher than they would be at the average antique shop in Indiana!  

Antiques vs. Vintage – What’s the Difference?

When browsing the mall, it’s important to know the difference between “vintage” and “antique” items. Vintage refers to anything that is at least 20 to 99 years old, while antiques must have been made at least 100 years ago. If you’re searching for Indiana antique shops for something a bit newer, but still has an extra special touch, take a closer look at the handmade booths or upcycled pieces!  

Favorite Indiana Antique Mall Finds:

The best Indiana antique malls have a wide variety of items, such as:

• Collectibles: Disney figurines, antique dolls, Dungeons and Dragons dice, etc.

• Upcycled goods: reupholstered sofas, repurposed textiles, vintage suitcase shelves, etc.

• Furniture: antique desks, mid-century modern coffee tables, vintage bedframes, etc.

• Memorabilia: valuable sports jerseys, signed baseballs, vintage VHS movies, etc.

• Home décor: framed artwork, street signs, vintage Mason jars, etc.  

• Handmade gifts: luxury soaps, local honey, scented candles, crocheted blankets, etc.

• Toys: Sesame Street stuffed animals, vintage Barbie dolls, limited edition Hot Wheels, etc.

Planning Your Trip to an Indiana Antique Mall

Why wait until a birthday or holiday rolls around to try your hand at antiquing? Now is as good a time as any to explore the Indiana antique mall in your area! Whether you’re stopping by solo or bringing the whole family along for the adventure, planning your trip to antique malls like ours is easier than you think!

With an ever-changing selection of items, you can never be sure about what you’ll find—and that’s half the fun! While smaller Indiana antique shops have limited space, antique malls have room for heavy pieces of furniture, massive paintings, and more. With that in mind, we recommend making space in your car before you head out to ensure you have room for whatever large treasures you stumble upon.

Choosing the Best Antique Mall for Your Visit

If you’re interested in shopping at Indiana antique malls, you may find yourself asking, “Where do I even start?” When it comes to deciding which antique mall is right for you and your interests, it all boils down to a few specific considerations:

• Distance away from your home base: How far away is the Indiana antique mall from your office or work?

• Ratings and reviews: Do customers speak highly of the vendors and items? Do they mention whether or not they have repeat customers?

• Size: How big is the space? How many vendors do they allow to rent booths and showcases in their location? Is it noticeably bigger than the other Indiana antique shops in the area?

• Items: If you’re searching for a specific kind of collectible, do they have it in stock? Are the vendors known for any niches?

• Events: Do they host any events? What age ranges do those events target?

Shopping at America’s Antique Mall in Indiana

As far as thrifting goes, America’s Antique Mall is one of the best options around! With 60,000 square feet of space to explore, this is certainly not your grandmother’s Indiana antique shop. With more than 600 vendors touting unique wares under a single roof and a continually updated inventory full of vintage and antique finds and brand new boutique-worthy items, your shopping trip is bound to be more fruitful here than anywhere else.

Whether you are coming to our Highland America’s Antique Mall for an hour on your lunch break or you’re prepared to dive in for an entire day, you will not be disappointed. Remember, if a collectible item is rare, vintage, or antique, there’s a good chance that, once these items are sold, they’re gone! If you see something you love at the Indiana antique shop, grab it before it’s too late.

What Sets Indiana’s America’s Antique Mall Apart?

With hundreds of vendors, you can trust that you’ll see fresh collections and make new discoveries every time you swing by our Highland location when antique shopping in Indiana. And with Eatery 41 right on-site, you can celebrate your finds with a toast!

Thanks to Eatery 41, you don’t have to worry about having a meal before you come or leaving when you or your companions get hungry. Instead, feel free to take a break from exploring the aisles and grab a snack or a cup of coffee, wine, or beer whenever you feel like it! Once you’ve refueled, you’ll be ready to head back out to search the Indiana antique shop to your heart’s content.

Benefits of Shopping at America’s Antique Mall in Highland, IN

• Remarkable customer experience

• An exceptional variety of antique, vintage, and handmade items

• Warm, welcoming aisles filled with different vendors

• Kind and knowledgeable staff

• Fun, exciting in-store events for your whole family

Connect with Your Community at an America’s Antique Mall Indiana Event

While we know the sheer volume of our antique, vintage, and upcycled goods is enough to start your engines in our direction, we also have exciting in-store events in Highland happening all year long. Here are a few of our most notable:

• Car show in July, featuring more than 100 cars

• Seasonal visits from Santa and the Easter Bunny, with free photos

• Monthly Book Club at the Café

• Monthly Comedy Club at the Café

• Monthly Vendor-Led topical events (e.g., plants, fishing lures, furniture refinishing, gardening)

While small mom-and-pop Indiana antique shops will always have a place in our hearts, sometimes you want a store that’s big, beautiful, and chock-full of discoveries waiting to be unearthed! When that’s the case, come visit and see all we have to offer at America’s Antique Mall in Highland, IN! Your Indiana antique shopping adventures will never be the same.